Lake-model PSII fluorescence: Gu et al. (2019)
Run the example, or view its panels in the gallery. Parameters, units and the digitized figure values are in gu_2019.toml.
Gu, Han, Wood, Chang and Sun (2019, New Phytologist 223:1179–1191, doi:10.1111/nph.15796) write the fate of PSII excitation as a competition between four first-order rates (fluorescence
With
and their ratio does not contain NPQ. With PSII excitation
An observed flux
What is implemented
| Paper | Package |
|---|---|
LakeModelFluorescence | |
Eqs. 14, 16 (yields from NPQ), Eq. 17 after multiplying by | lake_model_yields |
Eq. 16 solved for NPQ from | fluorescence with PSIIOpenFractionInputs or CoupledPhotosystemInputs |
| Eq. 21 ( | electron_flow_from_fluorescence with ObservedFluorescenceInputs |
| Eq. 23 (assimilation at the chloroplast from | electron_limited of carbon_assimilation with that |
LakeModelFluorescence is a fluorescence component like RateCompetitionFluorescence and CytochromeFluorescence: the same fluorescence call evaluates it, and it accepts the inputs that fluorescence_inputs returns for CytochromePhotosynthesis.
lake = LakeModelFluorescence(; maximum_photochemical_yield = 0.83,
heat_to_fluorescence_ratio = 19.0, yield_tolerance = 1e-12)
inputs = fluorescence_inputs(cytochrome_photosynthesis, site, excitation)
fluorescence(cytochrome_fluorescence, inputs) # Johnson & Berry (2021)
fluorescence(lake, inputs) # Gu et al. (2019), PSII only
electron_flow_from_fluorescence(lake, LeafPhotosynthesis.ObservedFluorescenceInputs(;
photon_flux = 2.0, escape_probability = 0.8, psii_fraction = 1.0, psii_open_fraction = 0.5))The model has no closure: NPQ follows from it and the electron flow. Eq. 24 of the paper (diffusion from ambient air to the chloroplast with three resistances) is not a package function; the example solves its carbon_assimilation.
Not implemented: the C4 forms (Eqs. 25–27), the chloroplast-envelope resistance of Eq. 24, a predictive model of
Relation to the Johnson & Berry (2021) model
For connected PSII units with exciton transfer rate CytochromeFluorescence uses a photochemical yield that tends to the lake expression above as CytochromeFluorescence; the tests confirm that the two return the same PSII yields and NPQ for the same inputs when
| Gu et al. (2019) | Johnson & Berry (2021) | |
|---|---|---|
| PSII antenna | lake ( | connected units, |
| Open fraction | input ( | predicted from Cytochrome |
NPQ | input, or implied by | solved so that PSII delivers the electron flow the dark reactions use |
| PSI fluorescence | excluded | included; weighted in the PAM observer |
| Electron flow | from fluorescence (Eq. 21) or from light with NPQ (Eq. 17) | from light, |
| Maximum PSII yield | measured | rate constants (0.882); the apparent |
The figures of the paper
With NPQ digitized from Fig. 1c (Vitis vinifera, eight irradiances) and the caption values
Eq. 16 reproduces the plotted
of Fig. 4c within 0.002at every point.Eq. 14 gives
between 0.0098and0.0122. Theplotted in Fig. 4c, as digitized here, is 0.0124to0.0163, 26–33 % higher. This apparent inconsistency between figure and equation is consistent with the figure showing , Eq. 14 without the term in the bracket, which the digitized points follow within 1.5 %; a single different(it would have to be 14.0 to 14.9) fits less well, and with the plotted values the four yields sum to 1.06–1.18. The cause is not established: calibration of the digitization or a different convention in the figure remain possible. One input is not independent: the fourthNPQmarker of Fig. 1c is hidden and was reconstructed from the combination plotted in Fig. 4c. The paper's qualitative statement holds either way:varies by a factor 1.24over the light response whilehalves. Eq. 21 with series diffusion (Eq. 24 at
, solved by the package'sgas_exchangefor a prescribed electron flow) reproduces the five curves of Fig. 2a at their right end (SIF = 5) within0.07 μmol CO₂ m⁻² s⁻¹.
Flexas et al. (2002) Figure 2
In the lake model the normalized steady-state fluorescence of PSII is
for an unchanged probing light, PSII cross-section and optical weighting between the dark reference and the light-adapted state. A prediction of NPQ from somewhere. With
The example keeps the gas exchange, the drought schedule, the PSII and PSI rate constants and the PAM observer of the Flexas benchmark and changes only the fluorescence formulation. All three rows below are compared with the measured signal through the same observer (PSI supplies 39 % of dark
| Formulation | Closure | RMSE, 49 lit points of Fig. 2 | RMSE, Inset (PPFD 750) |
|---|---|---|---|
CytochromeFluorescence | 0.062 | 0.038 | |
LakeModelFluorescence, model | the same | 0.244 | 0.324 |
LakeModelFluorescence, transferred | apparent | 0.433 | 0.615 |
Without the PSI level (PSII emission alone against the measured signal) the first two rows score 0.180 and 0.290.
A fourth evaluation uses no photosynthesis model: NPQ of Fig. 1c in the first form above with 0.044 over the seven irradiances inside that curve's range, peak 1.44 against the observed 1.45), and the 0.123). By the identity above this is a consistency check of the digitized PAM quantities, not a prediction. Gu et al. do not state which treatment of Flexas et al. their Fig. 1c shows; the agreement suggests a leaf close to the well-watered ones.
The second and third rows are sensitivity experiments on how the lake relations might be closed; neither is a formulation Gu et al. propose. What they show:
Connectivity, with the open-center population held fixed. Johnson & Berry's
(their Eq. 22) is a population of open centers and can be placed in a lake antenna. With the dark-balanced PSII share of the benchmark, their light-limited electron flow is per PSII photon, whereis the PSI/PSII electron ratio and its value at the CO₂ of the dark balance. A lake then emits from PSII: within0.02of one at 21 of the 49 points and below it at the others, never above1.0002, while the observations rise to1.45. The same flow and population in connected units ( ) need less quenching (intrinsic PSIINPQ2.2against4.2at , PPFD516), andrises. The antenna assumption, not the population, makes the difference: the lake that a PSII-only fluorometer would report for the connected units, with (0.28where ), put into the lake relations with the samereturns the connected-units fluorescence and NPQexactly (tested). The Flexas walkthrough shows how the fit depends onbetween these limits and how it trades off against the PSI weight (connectivity and the dark level). Consistency between
and . With the electron flow fixed, and in Eq. 21 (tested); at fixedNPQthe sensitivity ofis the smaller . The transferred and the benchmark's electron flow do not belong together: at and PPFD729the benchmark's apparentis 0.26(PSII alone0.33), the PAM value of Fig. 4c at that light about0.45. The row therefore misses even the well-watered curve (0.80against1.45). Which electron flow is right for the Flexas leaves cannot be decided with the data in this repository; a PAM electron transport rate above the gas-exchange estimate is common and can reflect electron sinks other than carboxylation and photorespiration.Drought at one irradiance (Inset, PPFD 750). Every row shares the electron flow and falls with conductance, as observed. From
to the observedfalls by a factor 1.61,CytochromeFluorescenceby1.71, the lake withby 1.40, and the lake with the transferredby 2.9. Conditional on the benchmark's apparent electron flow, the open fraction that reproduces the observations falls from0.21to0.12, where the transferred curve has0.39at every stage; read the other way, Eq. 21 with the transferredreturns from the observed 1.8( ) to3.3( ) times that apparent flow.
The comparison does not establish that the hypotheses of CytochromeFluorescence describe these leaves: its row carries chosen biochemical parameters, a prescribed non-stomatal drought schedule and a PSI detector weight transferred from another instrument and species (see the chosen inputs). It shows that the lake relations need treatment-specific NPQ, or an equivalent electron flow, and that the result is sensitive to connectivity and to the observation model. A discriminating test needs the PAM record of each treatment (NPQ and electron transport rate against PPFD) with matched gas exchange; Flexas et al. measured these, but they are not digitized here. Sustained quenching or photoinhibition under drought, which would lower