Water-stress steady-state fluorescence ( ): Flexas et al. (2002) benchmark
Open the dedicated interactive Figure 2 & SIF formulation explorer, run the Julia benchmark, or view the summary panels in the interactive offline gallery. Model assembly lives in setup/flexas_2002.jl, and every grapevine parameter, unit, and subpixel-digitized Figure 2 observation (55 main-panel points across all six curves plus 6 Figure 2 Inset points) is isolated in flexas_2002.toml.
Flexas et al. (2002, Physiologia Plantarum 114:231–240, doi:10.1034/j.1399-3054.2002.1140209.x) measured simultaneous gas exchange (LI-6400) and steady-state chlorophyll fluorescence (Walz PAM-2000, 298.15 K) and
Peak suppression: maximum
declines from 1.448in well-watered vines ( ) to1.160under severe drought ( ).Leftward irradiance shift: in the digitized curves the photosynthetic photon flux density (
PPFD) at whichpeaks shifts from 729( ) and735( ) down to331( ) and108 μmol photons m⁻² s⁻¹( ).Sub-
high-light quenching & curvilinear conductance inset: under severe drought ( ), non-photochemical quenching pulls high-irradiancebelow dark ( ), producing a positive curvilinearvs. relationship ( 0.900 → 1.449) at (Figure 2 Inset).
Evaluating every steady-state fluorescence formulation in LeafPhotosynthesis.jl against these experiments separates structural mathematical constraints from parameter calibration.
1. Why single-variable empirical fits fail on Figure 2
In RateCompetitionFluorescence paired with SaturationQuenching (van der Tol et al. 2014, JGR Biogeosciences 119:2312–2327, Eq. 19), energy-dependent non-photochemical quenching
Because PPFD through the exact same scalar curve
Peak-height invariance across drought: changing
or rescales the horizontal coordinate (shifting where occurs along the PPFDaxis), but reaches the identical global peak at every conductance—1.461(at , for ) for the Cotton parameter set ( , , ) and1.451(at , for ) for the Flexas Drought parameter set ( , , ). Single-variablemodels therefore cannot reproduce the progressive 1.448 → 1.160peak suppression in Figure 2.High-light sign inversion in Cotton
: because Cotton saturatesnear by , further increases inincrease the numerator faster than the denominator, turningupward at high light and predicting higher under severe drought than under well-watered conditions ( 1.22stomatal-only /1.28combined at vs.1.18at at , and1.35vs.1.31at —opposite in sign to the Figure 2 Inset). Switching to the empirical Drought fit ( , which van der Tol et al. 2014 fitted directly to Flexas et al. 2002) restores sub-quenching at high irradiance ( 0.90at ), yet still leaves peak height fixed near1.45across all conductances.
2. Two-state Cytochrome mechanics and Walz PAM-2000 PSI leakage
CytochromePhotosynthesis + CytochromeFluorescence (Johnson & Berry 2021, Photosynthesis Research 148:101–136) resolves both limitations by separating two distinct physical state variables:
Thylakoid electron-supply poise
: open PSII trap fraction is governed by absorbed PSI excitationand Cytochrome plastoquinol oxidation capacity , independent of stromal . At low irradiance, carbon assimilation is light-limited ( ), dynamic feedback quenchingremains near zero, and progressive reduction of the plastoquinone pool ( decreasing with PPFD) drives the initial rise in. Stromal sink saturation
: once absorbed light exceeds the Rubisco + photorespiratory ceiling , realized linear electron yield falls below the unquenched connected-units envelope. Closing the PSII exciton budget induces lumen-pH feedback quenching , truncating the-driven fluorescence rise right at the transition. Loweringdraws down chloroplast , lowering so the crossover occurs at lowerPPFDwhereis still largely open—simultaneously lowering peak , shifting peak PPFDleftward, and driving high-light .
Apparent PAM fluorometry (PAMFluorescenceObserver)
Flexas et al. (2002) recorded >700 nm long-pass filter). The model weights far-red PSI emission twice as strongly as PSII emission (
Because oxidized dark_pam_levels predicts dark-adapted apparent 0.80–0.83 measured by Flexas et al. (2002, p. 234). This agreement depends on carrying the LI-6800 / P. fremontii estimate of the detector weighting over to the PAM-2000 and grapevine. Pure PSII emission (1.66 at 1.44).
3. Photorespiratory electron-sink floor and non-stomatal drought transition
Separating pure stomatal diffusion (enable_nonstomatal = false, fixed enable_nonstomatal = true) in the Figure 2 Inset (
Mild-to-moderate drought (
): pure stomataldrawdown quantitatively tracks both Figure 2 ( RMSE = 0.049–0.061) and the Figure 2 Inset (1.41 → 1.39 → 1.35stomatal-only and1.41 → 1.36 → 1.23combined vs. observed1.449 → 1.369 → 1.229).Severe drought (
): pure stomatal closure hits the photorespiratory sink floor ( at for , and as where day respiration holds ), preventing the model's Figure 2 peak from shifting below~350–400 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹orfrom dropping below ~1.08. For the model to move the severe-drought peaks down to200 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹( ; digitized:108) and to reach sub-high-light (0.73–0.88at ), it needs a non-stomatal biochemical downregulation. Such downregulation is documented in Vitis vinifera when prolonged drought reducesbelow 80–100 mmol m⁻² s⁻¹(Escalona et al. 1999; Flexas et al. 2002, Fig. 3A & p. 239). The model represents it by a smooth Hill transition retaining60%and 85%as ; its half-conductance, exponent and floors were chosen by the author, were not fitted to the digitized points and have no Tempranillo-specific source in this repository (see inputs chosen, not fitted).
4. Physiological controls: high- reversion, qT state transitions, and DTT {#4.-Physiological-controls:-high-\mathrm{CO_2}-reversion,-qT-state-transitions,-and-DTT}
The fourth benchmark panel tests three experimental perturbations at severe water stress (
High-
/ -depleted reversion (Flexas et al. 2002, Fig. 3C): switching ambient air ( , ) to (1500 ppm) inbalance ( ) bypasses stomatal diffusion limitation, restores carboxylation ( at and at , matching Fig. 3A's~12.5), relieves feedback, and restores to 1.45–1.52across high irradiance—confirming that the severe-drought depression is driven primarily by stromal electron-sink restriction rather than irreversible PSII photoinhibition.Closed-form LHCII state transitions (
StateTransitionRule,qT): in a static connected antenna ( ), exciton sharing boosts PSII efficiency as traps close and induces small positive feedback even in the Cytochrome-limited low-light regime (Case 9), damping the low-lightrise ( 1.30). AllowingStateTransitionRule(Case 10) to migrate LHCII from PSII to PSI ( ) maintains up to Rubisco saturation while increasing PSI emission (weighted2×by the assumed detector weighting), raising the model's low-light apparentpeak to 1.76before decaying under high-light feedback( 1.18at ). Flexas et al. (2002) observed a damped peak (1.219) at , not a spike like the model's1.76. This misfit suggests the hypothesis that water-stressed grapevine leaves operate closer to static antenna partitioning than to full state-transition rebalancing; it is not a finding, since other model inputs (for example, the detector weighting or ) could also cause the misfit. DTT xanthophyll-cycle inhibition (Flexas et al. 2002, Fig. 5): evaluating
RateCompetitionFluorescencewithConstantQuenching(0)( ) removes energy-dependent thermal dissipation, causingto climb monotonically past 2.3–4.5as traps close—matching dithiothreitol-infiltrated leaves in Figure 5.
Connectivity , the PSI weight and the dark level
Two quantities set the size of the modeled signal and have no direct calibration for these leaves or this instrument: the exciton transfer rate between PSII units, 2 ns⁻¹ and 2.0) over. This section is a sensitivity analysis with every other input of the benchmark held fixed: the drought schedule,
For fixed rate constants, zero sustained quenching and a static antenna, the PSII fluorescence relative to
with
Size of the signal. For the well-watered leaf (2.53, 1.72 and 1.22 for 2 and 10 ns⁻¹.
What the assumed observer predicts. These are PSII yields. A fluorometer adds the PSI level to 1.94, 1.44 and 1.13; only these compare with the measured 1.45. The constant level holds for this observer: PSI yield independent of P700 state (
Below 2100 for all three transfer rates. Under severe drought (450, 375 and 250 on (first sampled points of the 25-unit grid) and end at 0.58, 0.55 and 0.49 (0.75, 0.73 and 0.68 as the observer predicts them: a constant PSI level compresses the signal around 20 Pa, static antenna) the yield at 1.53 1640 on and ends at 0.88 2400; at 10 ns⁻¹ it is below from PAR 940 on and ends at 0.72. These crossings are our calculations, not values stated in the paper. Extending the same simulation to other prescribed CO₂ levels, it stays above 40 Pa and ends at 0.59 at 10 Pa (tested).
A trade-off, bounded by dark
weight 0 | 2.0 | 2.5 | smallest on the grid 0–6 (weight) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
0.5 | 0.588 | 0.287 | 0.246 | 0.088 (6.0) |
1 | 0.360 | 0.151 | 0.123 | 0.047 (6.0) |
1.5 | 0.247 | 0.088 | 0.070 | 0.049 (4.0) |
2 | 0.180 | 0.062 | 0.055 | 0.054 (3.0) |
3 | 0.115 | 0.070 | 0.075 | 0.068 (1.5) |
5 | 0.107 | 0.113 | 0.118 | 0.102 (0.5) |
10 | 0.167 | 0.164 | 0.165 | 0.163 (1.0) |
Judged by the 49 lit points alone, a lower transfer rate with a larger PSI weight does as well as the carried-over pair: the smallest error per transfer rate lies between 0.047 and 0.068 from 3 ns⁻¹. No error model for the digitized points is available, so these differences are not shown to be significant either way.
The PSI weight is constrained by a second measurement, however. With 0.882 without PSI, 0.821 at weight 2.0, 0.807 at 2.5, 0.794 at 3.0, 0.768 at 4.0 and 0.721 at 6.0. Flexas et al. (2002, p. 234) report 0.80–0.83 for all leaves examined, which admits weights of about 1.7 to 2.8 (PSI share of dark 2.0 and 2.5), 0.062, 0.055), 1.5 and 3 follow (0.070–0.088), and 1 and 5 are clearly worse (0.11–0.15).
Both constraints are conditional on the fixed inputs listed above, which shape 0.94 times the weight tabulated here: the 1.6 to 2.6. Within those conditions the benchmark supports that range of the product and 1.5 and 3 ns⁻¹; it is not a calibration of either. A direct constraint on connectivity would need controlled fast-induction measurements interpreted with an explicit connectivity and kinetic model.
5. Summary across SIF / fluorescence yield formulations
Inputs chosen, not fitted
No parameter was fitted to the digitized fluorescence points. The following model inputs were chosen by the author and have no Tempranillo-specific source in this repository (flexas_2002.toml):
the non-stomatal Hill schedule
[nonstomatal_drought]:half_conductance_mmol = 56.0(mmol H₂O m⁻² s⁻¹),hill_exponent = 4.0,vcmax_severe_floor = 0.60andvqmax_severe_floor = 0.85; (site_density = 0.58μmol sites m⁻² at ); (mesophyll_co2 = 0.20); at298.15 Kand21 kPaO₂ (gamma_star_ref_Pa = 3.70).
The schedule matters: with stomatal diffusion alone the lit Figure 2 RMSE is 0.097 and the Inset RMSE 0.144; with the schedule they are 0.062 and 0.038 (the two Cytochrome + PAM rows below). The detector weighting
PSII yield and detector signal
A PSII fluorescence yield is not what a fluorometer reports. The assumed observer adds a PSI level that is constant here, so its share of each level changes as PSII is quenched: 39 % of dark 7 % of dark 27 % (well watered, at the peak) to 51 % (severe drought, high light) of 48 % of 1222 the model has 0.093 against an apparent 0.048, NPQ 11.5 against 6.0, and 0.17 against 0.21. The PSII yields themselves are unchanged.
Each formulation is scored twice against the 49 lit points: as the PSII ratio, and through the observer (detector_level, with the same weights, measuring-beam fractions and PSI level for all):
| Formulation | RMSE, PSII ratio | RMSE, with PSI level | with PSI, | with PSI, |
|---|---|---|---|---|
CytochromeFluorescence | 0.180 | 0.062 | 0.049 | 0.092 |
| Cotton | 0.152 | 0.132 | 0.210 | 0.161 |
| Drought | 0.118 | 0.118 | 0.205 | 0.065 |
For the mechanistic model the observer is the proper comparison, and it changes the picture. For the empirical fits the second column is a sensitivity case, not a correction: van der Tol et al. (2014) estimated their constants from fluorometer signals in which PSI was not corrected out, so their yields already represent both photosystems, and the unaugmented column follows that calibration more closely. Adding the prescribed PSI level on top mixes the two interpretations: it lowers their dark 0.80 to 0.71, below the measured 0.80–0.83, and pulls their well-watered peak (1.46) down to about 1.28.
The observer is an assumption throughout: weights carried over from another instrument and species, the measuring-beam fractions set equal to the actinic dark-balanced ones for every formulation, and fixed weights standing in for wavelength-dependent emission, reabsorption and detector response. Its 39 % PSI share of dark 700 nm, which is wide: 24 % in Arabidopsis (Pfündel et al. 2013), about 30 % in C3 leaves (Pfündel 1998), 41 % computed for an RG9 long-pass filter from isolated spinach PSI and PSII spectra (Bos et al. 2023) and 45 % in cherry laurel (Pfündel 2021). It should not be read as a general correction for this instrument. The lake-model rows of the Gu et al. comparison pass through the same observer.
Peak positions
The digitized Figure 2 curves peak at PPFD = 729, 735, 516, 322, 331, 108 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹ for 331 and 441 tie). The model (CytochromeFluorescence + PAMFluorescenceObserver, stomatal + non-stomatal) peaks at 1050, 675, 525, 475, 325, 200 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹ on its 25 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹ grid. Its well-watered peak lies ~320 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹ above the digitized one, a mismatch.
Formulations
Formulation in LeafPhotosynthesis.jl | Dark | Lit Fig. 2 RMSE ( | Inset RMSE ( | Peak | High-light |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
ConstantQuenching(0) (DTT / | 0.800 | — (DTT control) | — | None (climbs to 4.47) | No (matches DTT-infiltrated leaves only, Fig. 5) |
SaturationQuenching — Cotton | 0.800 | 0.152 | 0.224 | No (invariant 1.45–1.46) | No (1.35 at 1400, inverted drought sign) |
SaturationQuenching — Drought | 0.800 | 0.118 | 0.157 | No (invariant 1.45) | Yes (0.90 at 1400, empirical fit to Flexas) |
CytochromeFluorescence (pure PSII, | 0.882 | 0.180 | 0.168 | Yes (1.72 → 1.36), over-amplified | Yes (0.60 at 1400) |
CytochromeFluorescence + StateTransitionRule (qT) + PAM-2000 | 0.821 | 0.402 | 0.493 | Overshoots (2.30 → 1.55) | Yes (0.91 at 1400) |
CytochromeFluorescence + PAMFluorescenceObserver ( | 0.821 | 0.097 | 0.144 | Partial (1.44 → 1.29, floor at | Floor near 0.95 (1.08 at 750) |
CytochromeFluorescence + PAMFluorescenceObserver ( | 0.821 | 0.062 | 0.038 | Yes for the height (1.44 → 1.22 vs. obs. 1.45 → 1.16); mismatch in position at 1050, digitized 729) | Yes (0.75 at 1400, 0.82 at 750) |
6. Scope limits
All simulations are steady-state point evaluations; slow dark-to-light induction and photoinhibitory recovery timescales (
qIrelaxation) are not modeled.In
CytochromeFluorescence, regulated thermal dissipationis solved algebraically to close the PSII exciton budget without an upper xanthophyll/PsbS saturation ceiling ; at extreme drought and high light ( , ), unboundedslightly over-quenches ( 0.75–0.77vs. observed0.91–0.94).Pre-escape photosystem yields and PAM detector ratios (
) describe leaf-level fluorometry; canopy-leaving solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence (SIF) additionally requires spectral PSII/PSI emission shapes, within-leaf chlorophyll reabsorption ( 685 nmvs.740 nm), and canopy radiative transfer inCanopyOptics.jl.